Boost Website User Engagement with Pop-Up Notifications [2023 Edition]

Ever noticed your favorite brand announcing a flash sale through a quirky banner that pops out of nowhere? Or has a website made a buying recommendation complementary to the product or service you bought?

Seasoned marketers know that discovery is critical to building successful products. Almost 50% of buyers make unplanned purchases on receiving a personalized nudge! For instance, here’s a perfect example of Marks and Spencer using a pop-up notification to inform users about an offer.

It’s a remarkable way to time pop-ups to a user’s action. In this case, if a user spends too much time on the website and doesn’t buy, M&S lures them with an offer. What a cool way to nudge users. Right?

Pop-ups are touted to be a powerful tool in the marketer’s arsenal to enhance customer experience at every touch point. Using rich media like images and emojis & personalized targeting becomes an incredibly seamless way to deliver messages to active customers and help them discover something unexplored on the website.

How are pop-ups different from push notifications?

Pop-up notifications are a new mini browser, banner, or window a user didn’t intentionally open. They just appear on the website while browsing. The most common use case of pop-up notifications is to inform a user about a significant update or offer.
Push notifications (PNs) are a style of messaging delivered to the user directly on the lock screen or home screen. In other words, PNs are delivered to the user even when they are not active on the website, web or app. They can be agnostic of any user event at that moment.

Take a look at some of the critical differences between push & pop-up notifications:

Importance & benefits of pop-up notifications

In an article published by Optimonk, the average conversion rate for a website pop-up is around 11%, making pop-ups one of the most effective ways to convert users. Thus, a well-designed pop-up targeted at the right users can unlock several essential goals which include:

• Higher engagement: Contextual and well-timed messaging based on where the user is in their buying journey can prove incredibly valuable in keeping users engaged. Braze claims engagement is 131% higher among users who received pop-ups than those who did not.
• Increased retention: Pop-ups are the e-commerce equivalent of someone who greets you at the store. Using pop-up notifications at high friction points, like a paywall or data collection page, can reduce user churn. All you must do is keep the messaging crisp, contextual, & attention-grabbing.



• Better conversion rates: Imagine a well-timed discount coupon popping up on the user’s screen just before purchase or a countdown pop-up that creates a sense of urgency – these personalized pop-ups lead to instant conversions.

According to Drop, anything shown around the 8th second works 3x better than those shown before or after.

Improved user experience: Leveraging pop-up notifications to guide a new user through their website or app journey improves user experience multifold. Users targeted by pop-ups in their first session had a 90% higher retention rate because they were exposed to their AHA moments sooner than later.

A website pop-up aims to motivate users with an intuitive and straightforward prompt that brings value to their experience and elicits action. These meaningful experiences drive them towards instant gratification and reduce friction in the journey.

Why do you need to use pop-ups?

Pop-ups help in achieving everything from higher engagement to better retention. But the success of any pop-up campaign (measured by click-through rates) depends on answering four essential questions: who, when, where, and why.

Here, click-through rate (CTR) is a function of who is receiving the pop-up (audience), when & where they are receiving it (timing & placement), and why they are receiving it (purpose & targeting)!

To achieve a higher CTR, marketers must define the why (i.e. the goal). For instance, if you want to increase AOV or improve the health of cart abandonment, should you show a pop-up on the checkout page or while the customer is browsing? This decision needs to be made post-traffic analysis of the website that tells you when your customer really drop.

• Acquisition: Pop-ups don’t support direct or new customer acquisition; however, they can help you resurrect inactive customers. Ever wondered how a website knows when you’re about to leave your cart and move on?

What goes in the backend is out of our syllabus, but exit intent pop-ups are among the most popular marketing strategy to reduce cart abandonment Here’s an example from GetResponse asking visitors to subscribe before they go.


• Engagement: Imagine a highly active user slowly inching towards a dormant phase – In such a case send them a pop-up reminding them about their core activity or new proposition that may reactivate the users..

It reflects the bond between the user and the brand and is measured by the number of times a user interacts with the brand, and pop-ups are a great way to motivate users to take action.

• Conversion: This is a core success metric that depicts how many users have ultimately taken the desired action ( product purchase, subscribing to a newsletter, or sharing information).

From full screen to those that slide in with information, conversion as a metric can benefit vastly from the versatility that pop-ups bring to the table. Here, Nykaa is showing its website visitors a pop-up to log in by enticing them with 2000 reward points.


• Retention: An indicator of loyalty, retention defines how many customers continue to use the product/service over time. You can use cohorts on WebEngage dashboard to identify dormant users and run campaigns to bring them back to life.

Identify a cohort that previously spent a lot of time with the brand or purchased it but doesn’t anymore. Send them a personalized nudge about an offer to reactivate them.

Once you know your goal, the next step is to identify the target audience. A few examples of target groups are new users, returning users, inactive users, social media followers, newsletter subscribers, or users who exited abruptly.

The last step is to decide on the timing & placement of the pop-up. Marketers can choose the most effective type of notification from a sea of predefined layouts on WebEngage (below are a few examples).

Use Cases for Personalized Pop-Up Notifications

Personalized pop-up notifications are known for being versatile and grabbing users’ attention. Here are examples of a few events based on which you can target customers better:

1. Page URL based: Personalisation based on which page or section of the website the users are in is called URL-based targeting.

For instance, if the readers of a blog on psychology are the best customers for a newly launched book, visiting this blog’s URL can be used as a trigger event.

2. Customer type based: Determine if it is a new, existing , or reactivated customer. This information can be used to run onboarding / conversion / re-engagement campaigns.

For instance, existing customers can receive recommendations based on their past purchases.

3. Geolocation based: Did the monsoon come early in a specific part of India? If you were an e-commerce marketplace, would you not suggest your users from a specific location to stock up for the rainy days? You could run targeted ads based on the geolocation of your user.
4. Time-based: Starbucks rewards people on their birthdays & anniversaries for being loyal members. This can be constituted as a time-based pop-up where time denotes an hour, a day, or any important event!
5. Transaction based: Want to incentivize users who have a cart filled with products worth a certain amount? Simply target them with discount pop-up notifications to complete their purchase. Transaction-based targeting also encompasses sharing of order status & other wallet updates.
6. Offer-based: Reaching out to users with an offer will surely have the highest conversions and generate much transaction-based value. These are the most impactful ways to resurrect plummeting sales, bring old users back, and share a new update.

Best Practices for Pop-Up Notifications

If you ask your next-door friendly marketer about why and how they use pop-ups for best results, their answer would be simply by facilitating the right information at the right time.

Here are some tips on how to make pop-ups the most effective tool in your marketing arsenal:

• Notification Schedule: Timing is not just about when to send notifications, but more importantly, about when not to. Users hate to be disturbed during bedtime or work hours. They also don’t want to hear from brands first thing in the morning or too often – so avoid that.

According to a study, CTR peaks between 12 to 2 PM.


• Personalizing notifications : Relevant & on-point messaging ensures better conversion & higher sales. So, ensure you know your customer’s individual needs & preferences for the success of your pop-up campaigns. Try their name or wordplay with the product they’re engaging with.
• Consistency and frequency of notifications: The message is often lost if the sending frequency of your pop-up notifications is low. But if the opposite happens, users may feel annoyed by the repetitive messaging, which could lead to uninstalls. To maintain the balance try to not send more than 2-5 notifications a week.
• Value of the message conveyed: Your pop-up adds no value if it doesn’t convey the message in a concise & simple manner. More importantly, if the CTA doesn’t redirect the user to the right place, they will merely drop off. Build precise journeys that make customer experience seamless.
• Ease to respond or exit: Pop-ups are attention-grabbing by nature. But don’t risk removing the exit option from it. Avoid forcing the user on a journey they don’t enjoy. Remember, even if the pop-up is closed, the message has reached them!

Tips to Design Effective Pop-Up Notifications

Getting your users to love pop-up notifications as much as you do is a function of four things: format, placement, copy, and design. And we’ve got you covered; this is how you can create the most compelling pop-up.

You must understand where to place the pop-up notification on the screen. Here are a few options to explore while setting up your pop-ups.

• Lightbox popups: As the name suggests, these pop-ups take over the user’s screen by covering the website’s content and making the background dim.

Best use case: An important messaging which drives your north star metric.


• Slide-in pop-ups: These pop-ups usually appear on a smaller portion of the screen, and do not interrupt the website contents otherwise. Here, you allow users to go about their business on the website without stopping or hindering their journey.

Best use case: They’re primarily used for service updates, showing deals, or redirecting to a new offering.


• Dialogue box pop-up: These are similar to the lightbox pop-up but slightly more engaging and interactive in nature. Lightbox pop-ups usually flash information, but the dialogue box usually expects users to engage – you can ask for details, feedback etc. A good-looking image or question can reinforce your argument, convey more information, and encourage action.

Best use case: When you want to collect or verify the information.


• Fullscreen welcome mat: Need we say more? They’re what they sound like – a full-screen welcome mat that’s hard to ignore. They guarantee a high click-through rate but at the expense of a poor experience. You never know if your users are in the mood for such an intrusion.

Best use case: Only the most critical business use case or discounts.


• Floating bar: Ideally placed at the top or the bottom of the page, floating bars are a common website information disbursal layout. Like the slide-in pop-ups, they are highly non-intrusive and commonly used for a quick update.

Best use case: Promotional message or an update.

Once the placement is determined, you must choose the event that triggers the pop-up. Does that pop-up appear on

1. Click: when a link, image, or button is clicked?
2. Scroll: when the user reaches a specific point on the page?
3. Time delay: when a user spends a predefined amount of time on the page.
4. Exit-intent: when a user attempts to leave the page.

On an average, 69% of carts are abandoned across industries, and websites – using a pop-up here could make or break your sales funnel. A discount? A testimonial? A freebie? Some free shipping? Run A/B tests on your audience, figure out what converts higher and then create a robust pop-up that compliments your website.

The next critical step is to write a compelling message. An impressive copy can potentially prevent users from perceiving pop-ups as intrusive and annoying. So, here are four tips on how to curate compelling pop-up copies:

1. Keep your message simple: Use action words, and instead of speaking about the features of your product, focus on how it benefits your users. Convey their incentives in an obvious, specific, and concise manner.
2. Back it up with social proof: Customers love to learn from others’ experiences. Strengthen your communication by sharing any form of testimonial, customer stories, customer ratings, or feedback to trigger social proof/influence.
3. Create FOMO: Humans are also social beings and react well to emotions such as exclusivity & urgency. Use powerful words to trigger the fear of missing out to get a desired action.
4. Have a clear CTA: Let the user know what you want them to do. Distinguish the CTA button by placing it in a box and using different colors & power words like “enter” or “subscribe”.

But can a great copy make up for bad design? No, design is equally (if not more) important for the success of a pop-up campaign! A Backlinko survey claims brighter-colored pop-ups outperformed dull ones by 51.3%.

So what goes into cooking a perfect pop-up?

• Using your brand colors and allowing users to generate maximum recall
• Writing a copy that elicits an emotion, & drives action
• Using fonts that align with your branding guidelines
• Creating snackable, & appealing visuals in conjunction with your offering
• Picking the perfect time slot to stay relevant

Here are a few more design elements that can make an impact:

1. Stay away from generic templates: Experiment with colors, elements, and typography to grab the user’s attention.
2. Retain the brand’s identity: For better brand recall, experiment within your brand’s guidelines for better brand recall.
3. Allow the CTA to breathe: Your call-to-action must be easy to find & prominent. A crowded design is unattractive, distracts the user & lowers the CTR.

Lastly, iterate while deciding the format, placement, copy, and design. Create multiple combinations, experimenting with the length of the copy, headlines, CTAs, and overall designs.

Top Ways to Leverage Pop-Up Notifications

Now that you know why pop-up notifications are important and how you can drive up engagement, retention, and acquisition using compelling notifications, it’s time to explore the use cases!

There are tons of use cases you can implement based on the kind of business goals you want to accomplish- from generating leads to getting conversions. Let’s take a look at some of the use cases you can get started with:

Informational Popups: Helps to display important announcements or updates related to your product or services. For instance, notify users about changes in store hours or policies, announce an upcoming sale or share about a new product upgrade.

Email List Popups: Mostly used to cultivate email addresses from website visitors. It allows to connect with users by sending personalized products/services recommendations to boost engagement and conversions.

Cookie Popups: Comply with GDPR and ePrivacy Directive by requesting cookie consent. Cookie popups inform users about data collection and usage on the website. They are the best solution to inform your users that you save their data.

User Login Popups: Similar to email popups, it simplifies the login process for users by offering a popup login form. It allows to improve the user experience by enabling hassle-free login process.

Cart Abandonment Popups: The purpose of a Cart Abandonment Popup is to entice potential buyers with discounts or incentives, to reconsider leaving the site without completing their purchase. These type of targeted pop-up notification are mostly used by an e-commerce website or online store.

Testimonial and Feedback Popups: Customer interest rely heavily on social proof. Displaying customer testimonials to build trust and credibility is an excellent way to give a personal touch and humanize your brand.

Using pop-up notifications effectively can significantly improve user engagement, lead generation, and conversion rates. The possibilities for marketers to utilize pop-ups as a medium to reach out to their users, and speak to their customers at an optimal time are endless. However, it’s essential to use them thoughtfully and considerately to avoid overwhelming users and negatively impacting the user experience.

Limitations of pop-ups & how to avoid them

Website pop-ups are an incredible way to talk to your users and deliver information without much hindrance. However, it’s worth knowing what not to do – because simple mistakes can cause any campaign to tank.

1. Demotivate users to engage: Too many prompts can ruin user experience. Do keep a check on the frequency & timing of your pop up notifications so as not to annoy users.

An ideal strategy is using the average time spent by a user on your website and then marking a threshold of 50-60% to show a pop up, claims wiseapps.


2. Use generic templates & irrelevant messaging: Repetitive designs, copy, or irrelevant information is a big turn-off. To avoid this, marketers must approve only those campaigns that add true value to the business.

Track user engagement across a variety of pop up designs, placement, events, or activities. Chartbeat claims that most users who scroll below the fold tend to spend more time on the page down than page up.


3. Miss mobile optimization: As many as 75% web designers feel that non responsiveness of a website for mobile is the reason why users leave it, claims Sonary.

With an increasing number of users operating websites from their mobile, mobile optimization of pop-ups can’t be skipped. Make sure it meets the aesthetic and is not too intrusive.


4. No testing: Creating a great pop-up that converts, is contextual, talks to the users, offers value is no rocket science, however, requires some thoughtful thinking about users.

Before you take a pop up live, check on multiple devices, browsers, OS and locations. Test out the journey, CTA, and exit option.

Conclusion

Pop-up notifications are a definite game-changer for marketers struggling to improve website retention, and engagement. The key is in keeping things simple, and intuitive. WebEngage offers a suite of pre-built templates that are tried and tested by 100s of marketers.

Whether you’re looking to address cart abandonment or share an offer code – pop-up notifications can unblock you creatively. Effective pop-ups should be concise, appealing, crisp, and personalized. Need help in understanding what works best for your industry? Reach out to our team at WebEngage and harness the full potential pop-ups for your brand.